Horse coat color genetics: Bay, black, chestnut and more
Table of contents
- Pages in this section
- Base colors: chestnut, bay and black
- The extension gene (MC1R)
- The agouti gene in horses (ASIP)
- Worked example: two bays carrying black and chestnut
- Horse color chart: base colors and dilutions
- Dilution genes
- Cream
- Dun
- Champagne horse color
- Silver dapple horses
- Gray and white patterns
- What each gene teaches
- Common questions
- Is chestnut dominant or recessive?
- Can two black horses have a chestnut foal?
- Is a white horse the same as a gray horse?
- Why does a horse’s color name depend on its base color?
- Practice
- Where the model stops
- Related
- Sources
Level: School to high school · You’ll need: dominant and recessive alleles and a monohybrid cross · Start here: horse coat color calculator
Horse coat color genetics starts with two genes. The extension gene decides whether a horse can make black pigment at all, and the agouti gene decides where the black goes. Together they make the three base colors: chestnut, bay and black. Every other color, from palomino to gray, is one of those three base colors changed by another gene: a dilution gene that lightens it, a gray gene that turns it white with age, or a pattern gene that adds white.
This is CrossCalc’s horse genetics section. If you’ve come from cat genetics or mouse genetics, you’ll recognize some of the genes: horses share the agouti (ASIP), MC1R and KIT genes with cats, mice and people.
Assumptions for the crosses on this page: each gene has the two alleles shown, genes are inherited independently, and there are enough foals for the ratios to show. Ratios are chances for each foal, not promises.
Pages in this section
Tool
- Horse coat color calculator: choose nine coat genes for a mare and a stallion and see the chance of each foal color, with a Punnett square for every gene. High school and up.
Dilution genes
- Cream gene: palomino, buckskin, cremello: one copy or two copies of cream, and why palomino × palomino gives 1:2:1. High school.
- Dun gene: red dun, bay dun, grullo: a dominant dilution with a dark back stripe, buckskin vs dun, and the two non-dun alleles. High school.
Gray and white patterns
- Gray horses: a dominant gene that turns any color white with age. High school.
- Roan horses: white hairs mixed through the coat, and how breeding records answered whether two copies are lethal. High school.
- Paint horse patterns: tobiano, overo, sabino and splash, which have known genes, and Paint vs pinto. High school.
- Lethal white overo: the frame overo Punnett square, and why two copies are fatal. High school to college.
Base colors: chestnut, bay and black
The extension gene (MC1R)
The extension gene, sometimes called the “red factor”, has a dominant allele E and a recessive allele e. A horse with at least one E can make black pigment. An e/e horse makes only red pigment, so it is a chestnut (some breeds call a lighter shade “sorrel”).
The agouti gene in horses (ASIP)
In a horse that can make black pigment, the agouti gene decides where the black goes:
A(dominant) keeps black to the points: the mane, tail and lower legs. The body is reddish brown. That’s a bay.a/alets black cover the whole body. That’s a black horse. Theaallele is a small deletion that stops the agouti protein working.
Agouti can’t do anything visible on a chestnut, because a chestnut has no black pigment to move around. So a chestnut can carry A or a without showing it.
| Genotype | Base color |
|---|---|
E/- A/- | Bay |
E/- a/a | Black |
e/e with any agouti genotype | Chestnut |
A dash (-) means either allele.
Worked example: two bays carrying black and chestnut
Cross two bay horses that are both E/e A/a. Each gene is a 3:1 monohybrid cross, and you multiply the chances:
| Foal | Genotypes | Chance |
|---|---|---|
| Bay | E/- A/- | ¾ × ¾ = 9/16 |
| Black | E/- a/a | ¾ × ¼ = 3/16 |
| Chestnut | e/e (any agouti) | ¼ = 4/16 |
Instead of Mendel’s 9:3:3:1, you get 9 bay : 3 black : 4 chestnut. The “1” and one of the “3”s merge, because every e/e foal is chestnut whatever its agouti genes. When one gene hides another gene like this, it’s called epistasis. It’s the same 9:3:4 pattern that albino mice show. Check it in the calculator.
Horse color chart: base colors and dilutions
Dilution genes lighten a base color, but each one acts on a different pigment: red, black or both. That’s why the same gene gives a different name on each base color.
| Dilution gene | On chestnut | On bay | On black | Pigment it lightens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| None | Chestnut | Bay | Black | — |
| Cream, one copy | Palomino | Buckskin | Smoky black | Red (black barely changes) |
| Cream, two copies | Cremello | Perlino | Smoky cream | Red and black |
| Dun | Red dun | Bay dun | Grullo | Red and black, body only |
| Champagne | Gold champagne | Amber champagne | Classic champagne | Red and black |
| Silver | No visible change | Silver bay | Silver black | Black only |
Shades vary from horse to horse, so a chart like this gives the color group, not an exact shade. Breed registries also use their own names.
Dilution genes
Cream
Cream (SLC45A2) is the gene behind palomino, buckskin and cremello. One copy lightens red pigment to gold, and two copies lighten both red and black pigment to pale cream, with pink skin and blue eyes. Because one copy and two copies look different, cream is the standard horse example of incomplete dominance. The cream gene page works through the crosses.
Dun
Dun (TBX3) is dominant. It lightens most of the body but leaves darker primitive markings, most often a dark stripe along the back, and leaves the head, lower legs, mane and tail darker. Dun is thought to be the wild-type color of horses: Przewalski’s horses and wild relatives such as the kiang and onager are dun. Most domestic horses are non-dun, because of changes that switch TBX3 down in the hair follicle. There are two different non-dun alleles, and one of them is found in ancient horse DNA from before domestication. The calculator uses a single non-dun allele. The dun gene page has the crosses and the buckskin vs dun comparison.
Champagne horse color
Champagne (SLC36A1) is dominant and lightens both red and black pigment. Chestnut becomes gold champagne, bay becomes amber champagne and black becomes classic champagne. Champagne horses are also recognizable by their skin and eyes: foals are born with blue eyes and pink skin, and as they grow the eyes turn amber, green or light brown and the skin becomes mottled around the eyes and muzzle. Champagne can be hard to tell apart from cream by eye.
Silver dapple horses
Silver (PMEL), also called silver dapple, is dominant but acts only on black pigment. Its effect is strongest on the long hairs: a black horse with silver has a slightly lighter body, often with dapples, and a white or flaxen mane and tail. A bay with silver keeps its red body, but its mane, tail and legs lighten.
On a chestnut, silver has no obvious effect, because a chestnut has no black pigment for it to dilute. A chestnut can carry silver without it showing in her coat, and then have silver foals with a black-based partner. See it in the calculator. The same silver allele also causes an inherited eye condition, multiple congenital ocular anomalies (MCOA), which is more severe with two copies. The eye effects don’t depend on base color, so a chestnut carrying silver can have them too.
Gray and white patterns
- Gray (STX17,
G, dominant): foals are born with their other colors and lose hair pigment as they age, until most look white. Gray hides every other color gene in the end. - Roan (
Rn, dominant, near KIT): white hairs mixed through the body coat, while the head and legs stay mostly dark. - Tobiano (
TO, dominant): large white patches that usually cross the back. It’s caused by a large inversion (a flipped section) of chromosome 3 near the KIT gene. Horses with one or two copies usually can’t be told apart by eye; a DNA test can.
Other white patterns aren’t in the calculator; paint horse genetics covers them. Dominant white and sabino 1 are caused by other changes in KIT itself; frame overo by a change in EDNRB (two copies cause lethal white foal syndrome); splash white by changes in MITF and PAX3; and the leopard spotting of Appaloosas is linked to TRPM1.
What each gene teaches
| Gene | What you see | Genetics idea it teaches |
|---|---|---|
Extension (MC1R, E > e) | Black pigment or red only | Simple dominance |
Agouti (ASIP, A > a) | Bay or black | Epistasis: e/e hides agouti (9:3:4) |
| Cream (SLC45A2) | Palomino, buckskin, cremello | Incomplete dominance: 1 : 2 : 1 |
Dun (TBX3, D > d) | Lighter body, dark markings | Wild type vs later mutations |
Champagne (SLC36A1, Ch > ch) | Gold, amber, classic champagne | One gene affecting hair, skin and eyes |
Silver (PMEL, Z > z) | Pale mane and tail on black pigment | A gene that only shows on some backgrounds |
Gray (STX17, G > g) | Turns white with age | Dominant masking; a trait that changes with age |
Roan (Rn > rn) | White hairs mixed in | Testing whether an allele is lethal (3:1 vs 2:1) |
Tobiano (TO > to) | White patches | A dominant allele caused by a chromosome inversion |
Common questions
Is chestnut dominant or recessive?
Recessive. A chestnut is e/e, so two chestnut parents can only pass on e, and all their foals are chestnut (unless another gene, such as cream or gray, changes the color). Check it.
Can two black horses have a chestnut foal?
Yes, if both are E/e. Each foal then has a ¼ chance of being e/e and chestnut. Check it.
Is a white horse the same as a gray horse?
Usually not. Most horses that look white are grays that were born colored and turned white with age. Cremellos and perlinos are pale from birth because of two copies of cream. True white horses, born white, come from other genes (such as dominant white) that the calculator doesn’t model.
Why does a horse’s color name depend on its base color?
Because each dilution gene acts on a particular pigment. Cream lightens red pigment most, so it turns a chestnut gold (palomino) but leaves a black horse almost black (smoky black).
Practice
- A bay horse (
E/E A/a) and a chestnut (e/e a/a) have a foal. What colors are possible, and what’s the chance of each? - Two chestnuts have a foal. Can it be bay?
- A chestnut mare carries silver (
Z/z). Can you tell by looking at her?
Answers
- Every foal gets
Efrom the bay andefrom the chestnut, so every foal isE/eand can show black pigment. Agouti isA/a × a/a: ½A/a(bay) and ½a/a(black). So ½ bay, ½ black. - Not through extension and agouti. Both parents are
e/e, so every foal ise/e: chestnut (possibly diluted by another gene, such as cream). - No. Silver only acts on black pigment, and a chestnut has none. Her silver shows up only in foals that inherit
Efrom their other parent.
Where the model stops
- More alleles. Real horses have more alleles at several genes, such as a rare second recessive red allele at extension and two non-dun alleles. The calculator uses two per gene.
- Linked genes. Roan, tobiano and extension (MC1R) are all on chromosome 3, with roan and tobiano both near KIT, so they’re not fully independent. The calculator treats every gene as independent.
- Shade and names. Shade varies from horse to horse because of other, less understood genes, and breed registries use their own color names.
- More patterns. Frame overo, sabino, splash white, dominant white and leopard spotting aren’t modeled.
Across species: horse genes in cats, mice and people.
- MC1R: chestnut horses, sand-colored beach mice, and red hair in people. (The orange color of calico and orange cats comes from a different gene.)
- ASIP (agouti): bay versus black horses, tabby versus solid cats, and lethal yellow mice.
- KIT: roan and tobiano horses, dominant white cats and white-spotted mice.
- SLC45A2 (cream): pale horses, “underwhite” mice, and oculocutaneous albinism type 4 in people.
Related
- Horse coat color calculator: try any cross
- Cat genetics and mouse genetics: the other species sections
- Beyond Mendelian inheritance: incomplete dominance, epistasis and more
- Genetics glossary: plain definitions of allele, locus, genotype and more
Sources
- UC Davis Veterinary Genetics Laboratory. “Equine Coat Color Genetics.” vgl.ucdavis.edu/resources/horse-coat-color
- Rieder S, et al. “Mutations in the agouti (ASIP), the extension (MC1R), and the brown (TYRP1) loci and their association to coat color phenotypes in horses (Equus caballus).” Mammalian Genome 12, 450–455 (2001). doi:10.1007/s003350020017
- Mariat D, Taourit S, Guérin G. “A mutation in the MATP gene causes the cream coat colour in the horse.” Genetics Selection Evolution 35, 119–133 (2003). doi:10.1186/1297-9686-35-1-119
- Imsland F, et al. “Regulatory mutations in TBX3 disrupt asymmetric hair pigmentation that underlies Dun camouflage color in horses.” Nature Genetics 48, 152–158 (2016). doi:10.1038/ng.3475
- Cook D, et al. “Missense mutation in exon 2 of SLC36A1 responsible for champagne dilution in horses.” PLoS Genetics 4, e1000195 (2008). doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1000195
- Brunberg E, et al. “A missense mutation in PMEL17 is associated with the Silver coat color in the horse.” BMC Genetics 7, 46 (2006). doi:10.1186/1471-2156-7-46
- Andersson LS, et al. “Equine multiple congenital ocular anomalies and silver coat colour result from the pleiotropic effects of mutant PMEL.” PLoS ONE 8, e75639 (2013). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0075639
- Brooks SA, et al. “A chromosome inversion near the KIT gene and the Tobiano spotting pattern in horses.” Cytogenetic and Genome Research 119, 225–230 (2007). doi:10.1159/000112065
- Haase B, et al. “An equine chromosome 3 inversion is associated with the tobiano spotting pattern in German horse breeds.” Animal Genetics 39, 306–309 (2008). doi:10.1111/j.1365-2052.2008.01715.x
- Haase B, et al. “Allelic heterogeneity at the equine KIT locus in dominant white (W) horses.” PLoS Genetics 3, e195 (2007). doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.0030195
- Brooks SA, Bailey E. “Exon skipping in the KIT gene causes a Sabino spotting pattern in horses.” Mammalian Genome 16, 893–902 (2005). doi:10.1007/s00335-005-2472-y
- Santschi EM, et al. “Endothelin receptor B polymorphism associated with lethal white foal syndrome in horses.” Mammalian Genome 9, 306–309 (1998). doi:10.1007/s003359900754
- Hauswirth R, et al. “Mutations in MITF and PAX3 cause ‘splashed white’ and other white spotting phenotypes in horses.” PLoS Genetics 8, e1002653 (2012). doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1002653
- Bellone RR, et al. “Fine-mapping and mutation analysis of TRPM1: a candidate gene for leopard complex (LP) spotting and congenital stationary night blindness in horses.” Briefings in Functional Genomics 9, 193–207 (2010). doi:10.1093/bfgp/elq002
- Raudsepp T, et al. “Comparison of horse chromosome 3 with donkey and human chromosomes by cross-species painting and heterologous FISH mapping.” Mammalian Genome 10, 277–282 (1999). doi:10.1007/s003359900986