Lethal white overo: The frame overo Punnett square

Table of contents
  1. The frame overo allele
  2. The lethal white overo Punnett square
  3. From 1 : 2 : 1 to 2 : 1
  4. Frame overo × no frame pattern: N/O × N/N
  5. Why you can’t always see the frame allele
  6. Lethal white syndrome in horses and Hirschsprung disease in people
  7. Common questions
  8. What is the chance of a lethal white foal from two frame overo horses?
  9. Is the frame overo allele dominant or recessive?
  10. Do lethal white foals ever survive?
  11. Is every white foal from Paint parents a lethal white foal?
  12. Why isn’t frame overo in the horse coat color calculator?
  13. Practice
  14. Where the model stops
  15. Related
  16. Sources

Level: High school to college · You’ll need: a monohybrid cross and dominant and recessive alleles · Part of horse genetics

Lethal white overo is what happens when a foal inherits two copies of the frame overo allele. One copy (N/O) gives a horse the frame overo white pattern. Two copies (O/O) give a foal that is born all or almost all white and whose intestine is missing the nerve cells it needs to work. The condition is called lethal white foal syndrome (also overo lethal white syndrome, OLWS). There is no treatment, and affected foals die, usually within days of birth.

In a Punnett square for two frame overo parents, each foal has a ¼ chance of being O/O. That’s the same square as any cross between two heterozygotes. What’s different is how you read it.

Assumptions for the crosses on this page: one gene, EDNRB, with two alleles, N (the usual allele) and O (frame overo); every box in the square is equally likely; and the fractions are chances for each foal, not a count of how many foals a pair will have. This page explains the genetics as an example of a lethal allele. It isn’t breeding or veterinary advice; questions about a particular horse belong with a veterinarian.

The frame overo allele

The frame overo allele is a two-letter change in the gene EDNRB, which makes a receptor called endothelin receptor B. It puts lysine in place of isoleucine at position 118 of the receptor (written Ile118Lys). Before birth, this receptor helps two kinds of cells move from the neural crest, next to the developing spinal cord, to where they’re needed:

  • pigment cells, which travel into the skin, and
  • nerve cells of the gut, which travel along the intestine.
GenotypeCoatHealth (as reported by genetics labs)
N/NNo frame patternCan’t pass on O
N/OFrame overo: white on the sides of the body and neck, framed by color. Amount of white varies, and can be very smallHealthy; can pass on O
O/OAll or almost all whiteLethal white foal syndrome: no nerve cells in the end of the small intestine and the large intestine, so the gut can’t move food along. Fatal; no treatment

The genetics labs that test for this allele call its inheritance incomplete dominance, because each genotype looks different. For survival, though, O acts as a recessive allele: one copy is fine, two copies are fatal. That’s the same “dominant for one trait, recessive for another” pattern as the lethal yellow mouse.

The lethal white overo Punnett square

Cross two frame overo horses, both N/O:

NO
NN/N no frame patternN/O frame overo
ON/O frame overoO/O lethal white foal

At conception, the square gives ¼ N/N, ½ N/O and ¼ O/O: the usual 1 : 2 : 1. So each foal of two frame overo parents has a ¼ (25%) chance of having lethal white foal syndrome, a ½ chance of being frame overo and a ¼ chance of having no frame pattern.

See it in the Punnett square calculator, set up with a lethal genotype. The calculator writes N as o and O as O, crosses out the O/O box, and gives every ratio among surviving foals.

From 1 : 2 : 1 to 2 : 1

Among the foals that survive, cross out the O/O box first. Three boxes are left: two N/O and one N/N.

Among surviving foals: ⅔ frame overo, ⅓ no frame pattern. That 2 : 1 is the same ratio as two yellow mice.

There’s one real difference from the mouse. An Ay/Ay mouse embryo dies before it implants in the womb, so it’s never born and litters are smaller. A lethal white foal is born, and dies in the days after birth. So with horses, the ¼ is a chance for each foal born, and the 2 : 1 applies only to the foals that survive.

Frame overo × no frame pattern: N/O × N/N

NO
NN/N no frame patternN/O frame overo
NN/N no frame patternN/O frame overo

½ frame overo, ½ no frame pattern, and no chance of an O/O foal, because only one parent has an O to pass on. Check it.

Why you can’t always see the frame allele

If every N/O horse had an obvious frame pattern, this would be an easy cross to recognize. It isn’t, for two reasons:

  • Minimal white. The amount of white on an N/O horse varies a lot. Some carry the allele with so little white that they look solid.
  • Other patterns hide it. In the study that found the mutation, some tobiano horses carried O without a visible frame pattern, and a few horses carried it with no recognized overo pattern at all.

A study of 945 horses from white-patterned bloodlines concluded that a DNA test is the only way to know for certain whether a horse carries the frame allele. Veterinary genetics laboratories offer that test for breeds where the allele occurs, including Paint Horses, Quarter Horses, Miniature Horses and Thoroughbreds.

Lethal white syndrome in horses and Hirschsprung disease in people

The researchers who found the horse mutation called lethal white foal syndrome “an equine version of Hirschsprung disease”. In people, Hirschsprung disease is a condition in which part of the intestine lacks nerve cells, and some cases are caused by changes in the same gene, EDNRB. Changes in EDNRB in both copies can also cause a form of Waardenburg syndrome, which affects pigmentation and hearing as well as the gut. The shared gene explains why the same foals have both a white coat and a gut problem: pigment cells and gut nerve cells both depend on endothelin receptor B to reach their places in the embryo.

Common questions

What is the chance of a lethal white foal from two frame overo horses?

¼ (25%) for each foal. The parents are both N/O, so each foal has a ¼ chance of inheriting O from both. The chance is the same for every foal, whatever happened with earlier foals.

Is the frame overo allele dominant or recessive?

Both, depending on the trait. For the white pattern it’s dominant (one copy shows), and labs describe it as incompletely dominant because two copies look different again (all white). For survival it’s recessive: only O/O is fatal.

Do lethal white foals ever survive?

No foal with two copies of the frame allele is known to survive. Affected foals die, usually within days of birth, and a study of nearly 1,000 horses found no adult O/O horse. Some foals are born white for other reasons, such as two copies of sabino 1 or a dominant white allele, and those foals don’t have lethal white foal syndrome. That’s where stories of white “survivors” usually come from. A DNA test tells the two apart.

Is every white foal from Paint parents a lethal white foal?

No. Several genes can make a horse mostly or completely white (see paint horse genetics). Only O/O foals have lethal white foal syndrome.

Why isn’t frame overo in the horse coat color calculator?

The horse calculator is a coat color tool, and a lethal genotype in it could read like breeding advice. Frame overo is taught here with the general Punnett square calculator’s lethal-allele setting instead.

Practice

  1. Two N/O horses have a foal. What’s the chance it is frame overo?
  2. Two N/O horses have two foals. What’s the chance that both are O/O?
  3. Out of 300 foals born to N/O × N/O pairs, about how many would you expect to have lethal white foal syndrome? Among the foals that survive, what fraction would you expect to be frame overo?
  4. A frame overo horse has a foal with a horse that tests N/N. Can the foal have lethal white foal syndrome?
Answers
  1. ½ of all foals (the two N/O boxes out of four). Among surviving foals only, it’s ⅔.
  2. ¼ × ¼ = 1/16. Each foal is a separate event.
  3. About 75 (¼ of 300). The survivors are about 225, and about ⅔ of them (roughly 150) would be frame overo. Real numbers vary by chance.
  4. No. The N/N parent can only pass on N, so every foal is N/N or N/O. Check it.

Where the model stops

  • One mutation. The model has one frame allele. The genetics lab that tests for it notes a rare possibility of other, undiscovered mutations in the same gene, though none has been linked to lethal white foals so far.
  • The pattern varies. N/O horses range from very little white to a lot, so the coat isn’t a reliable genotype.
  • Other white genes. A horse can carry frame overo alongside tobiano, sabino or splash, which changes how it looks but not the ¼ chance for N/O × N/O.
  • Chances, not counts. ¼ is the chance for each foal. Two frame overo parents could have several foals without an O/O foal, or more than one.

Across species: lethal homozygotes. The lethal yellow mouse (Ay/Ay) is the classic textbook example: one copy changes the coat and two copies are fatal, giving 2 : 1 among the young that survive. Roan horses were once thought to be another example, but foal ratios showed that two copies of roan aren’t lethal. In people, EDNRB matters for pigmentation, hearing and the gut.

Sources

  • Santschi EM, et al. “Endothelin receptor B polymorphism associated with lethal white foal syndrome in horses.” Mammalian Genome 9, 306–309 (1998). doi:10.1007/s003359900754
  • Metallinos DL, Bowling AT, Rine J. “A missense mutation in the endothelin-B receptor gene is associated with Lethal White Foal Syndrome: an equine version of Hirschsprung disease.” Mammalian Genome 9, 426–431 (1998). doi:10.1007/s003359900790
  • Santschi EM, et al. “Incidence of the endothelin receptor B mutation that causes lethal white foal syndrome in white-patterned horses.” American Journal of Veterinary Research 62, 97–103 (2001). doi:10.2460/ajvr.2001.62.97
  • UC Davis Veterinary Genetics Laboratory. “Lethal White Overo (LWO).” vgl.ucdavis.edu
  • MedlinePlus Genetics. “EDNRB gene.” National Library of Medicine. medlineplus.gov
Try it: work out any cross with the horse coat color calculator, or a general one with the Punnett square calculator.