Paint horse genetics: Tobiano, overo, sabino and splash
Table of contents
- Paint vs Pinto: breed or color?
- The patterns and their genes
- Why “overo” is a group name
- Patterns can combine and hide each other
- Tobiano crosses
- Tobiano × solid: TO/to × to/to
- Two tobianos: TO/to × TO/to
- Homozygous tobiano × solid: TO/TO × to/to
- Frame overo: a pattern with a lethal homozygote
- Common questions
- What is the difference between a Paint and a pinto?
- What is the difference between tobiano and overo?
- Is tobiano dominant?
- Are all overo horses at risk of lethal white foals?
- Is a dominant white horse an albino?
- Is the Appaloosa pattern a paint pattern?
- Practice
- Where the model stops
- Related
- Sources
Level: High school · You’ll need: a monohybrid cross and the three base colors · Part of horse genetics
Paint horse genetics is the genetics of white patterns. A spotted horse is a horse of an ordinary base color (chestnut, bay, black and so on) with one or more white spotting genes on top. The main pattern names are tobiano, overo, sabino and splash. Several of them now have known genes: tobiano is a chromosome change near KIT, frame overo is a change in EDNRB, sabino 1 and dominant white are changes in KIT itself, and splashed white comes from changes in MITF and PAX3. Other pattern names are still just descriptions, with no single gene behind them.
Assumptions for the crosses on this page: each pattern gene has two alleles, the pattern genes are treated as inherited independently of each other and of the color genes, other genes are held the same, and there are enough foals for the ratios to show. Ratios are chances for each foal. This page explains inheritance only; it isn’t breeding advice.
Paint vs Pinto: breed or color?
“Paint” and “pinto” both describe horses with white patches, but they’re registry words, not gene names:
- A Paint is a horse registered with the American Paint Horse Association (APHA). It’s a breed registry: a Paint must have parents registered with the APHA, the American Quarter Horse Association or the Jockey Club (Thoroughbreds), and meet a color requirement.
- A pinto is any horse with a spotted coat, of any breed. Pinto registries are color registries.
So a spotted Arabian can be a pinto but not a Paint, and the same spotting genes turn up in both. Genetics describes the patterns; registries decide the names and the rules.
The patterns and their genes
White patterns come from pigment cells failing to reach, or survive in, parts of the skin while the embryo develops. Pigment cells start out in the neural crest, next to the developing spinal cord, and travel across the whole body. The genes below all affect that journey.
| Pattern | What it usually looks like | Gene | Inheritance (as taught) | Known gene? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tobiano | White crossing the back between withers and tail; legs usually white; head usually dark or with ordinary face markings; regular, rounded patches | Inversion (flipped section) of chromosome 3 near KIT | Dominant (TO) | Yes |
| Frame overo | White on the sides of the body and neck, “framed” by color; white rarely crosses the back; legs often dark; bold face white | EDNRB | One copy gives the pattern; two copies cause lethal white foal syndrome | Yes |
| Sabino 1 | White patches on the face, lower legs and belly, with white hairs mixed into the body (roaning) | KIT (SB1) | Incomplete dominance: two copies give a mostly white horse | Yes, for sabino 1 only |
| Splashed white | Very large blaze, white lower legs, variable white on the belly; often blue eyes | MITF and PAX3 (several alleles) | Dominant alleles, variable | Yes, for several alleles |
| Dominant white | Anything from a lot of white to an all-white horse | KIT (many separate alleles, such as W5, W10 and W20) | Dominant; two copies of some alleles are thought to be lethal before birth | Yes |
| Tovero | Features of both tobiano and overo | Not one gene: a name for a mix of patterns | — | Registry term |
Why “overo” is a group name
In registry use, “overo” has covered several patterns that look different from tobiano, such as frame overo, calico overo and splashed white overo, and horses described as sabino have been grouped with them. Genetic tests now show these come from different genes. In a study of 945 horses from white-patterned bloodlines, more than 94% of frame overo horses carried the EDNRB frame allele, but fewer than 21% of horses from sabino or splashed white overo lines did. So “overo” tells you something about a horse’s look, not its genotype.
Patterns can combine and hide each other
A horse can carry several white genes at once, and together they can add up to a lot of white. One pattern can also hide another: in the study that found the frame overo allele, some tobiano horses carried it without showing a frame pattern. Some horses with very little white carry it too. That’s why breed registries and owners use DNA tests instead of judging patterns by eye.
Tobiano crosses
Tobiano is the pattern the horse coat color calculator models, as TO (tobiano) and to (no tobiano). Horses with one copy and two copies usually look alike.
Tobiano × solid: TO/to × to/to
TO | to | |
|---|---|---|
to | TO/to tobiano | to/to solid |
to | TO/to tobiano | to/to solid |
½ tobiano, ½ solid (on whatever base color the foal inherits). Check it.
Two tobianos: TO/to × TO/to
¾ tobiano, ¼ solid. One foal in four (on average) is expected to be TO/TO, and it looks like any other tobiano. Check it.
Homozygous tobiano × solid: TO/TO × to/to
A TO/TO horse can only pass on TO, so every foal is tobiano (TO/to). Check it. This is the same logic as any test cross: a homozygous dominant parent gives every offspring the dominant allele.
Frame overo: a pattern with a lethal homozygote
Frame overo looks like an ordinary dominant pattern: one copy of the frame allele (often written O, with N for the usual allele) gives the pattern. But two copies cause lethal white foal syndrome: the foal is born white and its intestine lacks the nerve cells it needs, so it can’t survive. That makes frame overo × frame overo the horse version of the lethal yellow mouse cross. The lethal white overo page works through the Punnett square, including why the ratio changes from 1:2:1 to 2:1.
Frame overo is deliberately left out of the horse coat color calculator, so the calculator can’t be read as a breeding tool. The lethal white page uses the general Punnett square calculator instead.
Common questions
What is the difference between a Paint and a pinto?
Paint is a breed and pinto is a color. A Paint is registered with the American Paint Horse Association and has Paint, Quarter Horse or Thoroughbred parents. A pinto is any spotted horse, of any breed.
What is the difference between tobiano and overo?
On a typical horse, tobiano white crosses the back and the legs are white, while overo white usually doesn’t cross the back and the legs are often dark. Genetically, tobiano is one known allele near KIT. Overo is a group name that covers several different genes.
Is tobiano dominant?
Yes. One copy of TO gives the pattern, so every tobiano has at least one tobiano parent. One copy and two copies usually look alike.
Are all overo horses at risk of lethal white foals?
No. Only the frame overo allele in EDNRB causes lethal white foal syndrome, and only when a foal inherits two copies. Sabino and splashed white “overos” mostly don’t carry it. But the frame allele can be hidden by little white or by other patterns, which is why vets and registries recommend a DNA test rather than judging by the pattern.
Is a dominant white horse an albino?
No. In albinism, pigment cells are present but can’t make pigment, as in albino mice. Dominant white comes from changes in KIT, a gene that pigment cells need to survive as the embryo develops, so white areas lack pigment cells altogether.
Is the Appaloosa pattern a paint pattern?
No. Appaloosa (leopard complex) spotting is a different kind of pattern, linked to the TRPM1 gene rather than to the white-spotting genes on this page. The calculator doesn’t model it.
Practice
- A tobiano mare (
TO/to) and a solid stallion (to/to) have a foal. What’s the chance it is tobiano? - A tobiano stallion has ten foals with solid mares and all ten are tobiano. Does that prove he is
TO/TO? - A registry calls a horse “overo”. Can you tell from that word whether it carries the frame overo allele?
Answers
- ½.
TO/to × to/togives ½TO/to(tobiano) and ½to/to(solid). - No, but it’s strong evidence. If he were
TO/to, each foal would have a ½ chance of being tobiano, so ten tobianos in a row would have a chance of (½)¹⁰, about 1 in 1,024. A DNA test gives a definite answer. - No. “Overo” covers frame overo, sabino, splashed white and other non-tobiano patterns. Only a DNA test for the EDNRB allele tells you.
Where the model stops
- One pattern at a time. The crosses treat each pattern as independent. Tobiano, roan and sabino 1 are all at or near KIT on chromosome 3, so they’re linked, and real crosses can depart from these ratios.
- More alleles. Splashed white and dominant white each have many alleles, and some white patterns have no known gene yet.
- Amount of white varies. The same genotype can give very different amounts of white, so a pattern name isn’t a genotype.
- Not modeled. Frame overo, sabino, splash, dominant white and leopard complex aren’t in the horse calculator.
Across species: the same white-spotting genes. KIT gives tobiano, sabino and dominant white in horses, dominant white in cats, and white spotting in mice. EDNRB, MITF and PAX3 matter because they guide pigment cells (and, for EDNRB, gut nerve cells) as the embryo develops. In people, changes in PAX3, MITF and EDNRB are among the causes of Waardenburg syndrome, which can affect hair, eye color and hearing. Some splashed white horses are deaf, as are many blue-eyed white cats.
Related
- Lethal white overo: the frame overo Punnett square
- Horse coat color calculator: tobiano crosses with any base color
- Roan horses: another KIT-region pattern
- Gray horses: a horse that turns white with age is a different thing from a white pattern
- Horse genetics: the section overview
Sources
- Brooks SA, et al. “A chromosome inversion near the KIT gene and the Tobiano spotting pattern in horses.” Cytogenetic and Genome Research 119, 225–230 (2007). doi:10.1159/000112065
- Metallinos DL, Bowling AT, Rine J. “A missense mutation in the endothelin-B receptor gene is associated with Lethal White Foal Syndrome: an equine version of Hirschsprung disease.” Mammalian Genome 9, 426–431 (1998). doi:10.1007/s003359900790
- Santschi EM, et al. “Incidence of the endothelin receptor B mutation that causes lethal white foal syndrome in white-patterned horses.” American Journal of Veterinary Research 62, 97–103 (2001). doi:10.2460/ajvr.2001.62.97
- Brooks SA, Bailey E. “Exon skipping in the KIT gene causes a Sabino spotting pattern in horses.” Mammalian Genome 16, 893–902 (2005). doi:10.1007/s00335-005-2472-y
- Haase B, et al. “Allelic heterogeneity at the equine KIT locus in dominant white (W) horses.” PLoS Genetics 3, e195 (2007). doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.0030195
- Hauswirth R, et al. “Mutations in MITF and PAX3 cause ‘splashed white’ and other white spotting phenotypes in horses.” PLoS Genetics 8, e1002653 (2012). doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1002653
- UC Davis Veterinary Genetics Laboratory. “Equine Coat Color Genetics,” “Sabino 1” and “APHA White Pattern Registration Eligibility Panel.” coat color, sabino 1, APHA panel
- Oklahoma State University, Department of Animal and Food Sciences. “Breeds of Livestock: Paint Horses.” breeds.okstate.edu
- Bellone RR, et al. “Fine-mapping and mutation analysis of TRPM1: a candidate gene for leopard complex (LP) spotting and congenital stationary night blindness in horses.” Briefings in Functional Genomics 9, 193–207 (2010). doi:10.1093/bfgp/elq002
- MedlinePlus Genetics. “Waardenburg syndrome.” National Library of Medicine. medlineplus.gov