Dun gene in horses: Red dun, bay dun, grullo and markings

Table of contents
  1. What the dun gene does
  2. Primitive markings
  3. Dun colors: red dun, bay dun and grullo
  4. Buckskin vs dun
  5. Worked example: bay dun × buckskin
  6. Dun gene crosses
  7. Dun × non-dun: D/d × d/d
  8. Two duns: D/d × D/d
  9. Two copies of dun: D/D × d/d
  10. Grullo × red dun: three genes at once
  11. Two kinds of non-dun
  12. Is dun the wild type?
  13. Common questions
  14. Is dun dominant or recessive?
  15. Can two non-dun horses have a dun foal?
  16. What is the difference between buckskin and dun?
  17. Are horses with tiger stripes on their legs dun?
  18. Is a grullo the same as a gray horse?
  19. Practice
  20. Where the model stops
  21. Related
  22. Sources

Level: High school · You’ll need: a monohybrid cross and the three base colors · Part of horse genetics

The dun gene in horses is a dominant dilution. One copy of the dun allele D lightens the body coat but leaves the head, lower legs, mane and tail darker, and it adds primitive markings, most often a dark stripe down the middle of the back. Dun works on any base color: a chestnut becomes a red dun, a bay becomes a bay dun, and a black becomes a grullo.

Assumptions for the crosses on this page: the dun gene is written with two alleles, D (dun) and d (non-dun); the other genes are held the same; genes are inherited independently; and there are enough foals for the ratios to show. Each ratio is the chance for each foal, not a promise about a group of foals. Real horses have two different non-dun alleles; the section on non-dun1 and non-dun2 explains them.

What the dun gene does

The dun gene is TBX3. It doesn’t change which pigment a hair makes. It changes where the pigment goes in each hair. In a dun horse’s pale body hairs, pigment is laid down mostly on one side of the hair, the side facing out, and the rest of the hair is pale. That makes the coat look lighter overall. Hairs in the darker areas (the points and the markings) are pigmented all the way round.

Because dun works this way, it lightens both red and black pigment. Compare that with cream, which mostly lightens red pigment unless there are two copies (see the cream gene).

Primitive markings

Dun horses usually have some of these primitive markings:

  • a dorsal stripe: a dark line along the spine from the mane to the tail (the most consistent marking)
  • leg barring: dark horizontal stripes on the legs, sometimes called “tiger stripes”
  • a shoulder stripe across the withers
  • cobwebbing: faint dark lines on the forehead

How many markings show, and how clearly, varies a lot from horse to horse.

Dun colors: red dun, bay dun and grullo

Base colorWithout dun (d/d)With dun (D/-)What changes
Chestnut (e/e)ChestnutRed dunRed body lightened to tan or apricot; darker red points and markings
Bay (E/- A/-)BayBay dun (often just “dun”)Red-brown body lightened to tan or gold; black points stay black
Black (E/- a/a)BlackGrullo (also grulla)Black body lightened to a slate or mouse gray; head and legs stay dark

A dash (-) means either allele. Breed registries use their own names, and shades vary from horse to horse. Two dun-plus-cream names are also common: a palomino with dun is sometimes called a dunalino, and a buckskin with dun a dunskin.

D/D and D/d horses look the same: a second copy doesn’t make the dilution stronger. So dun is completely dominant for color, unlike cream.

Buckskin vs dun

This is the most common mix-up. A buckskin and a bay dun can both have a gold or tan body with black points. They come from different genes:

BuckskinBay dun
GeneCream (SLC45A2), one copyDun (TBX3), one or two copies
Pigment lightenedMostly red; black barely changesRed and black, on the body only
Dorsal stripe and leg barsUsually none from cream itselfUsually present
InheritanceIncomplete dominance (two copies make a perlino)Complete dominance (two copies look the same as one)

The clearest visible clue is the primitive markings. But some non-dun horses have a faint dorsal stripe too (see below), and shading on a buckskin’s back can look like a stripe. That’s why owners who need to know use a DNA test for each gene. A horse can have both genes at once: a buckskin with dun is a dunskin.

Worked example: bay dun × buckskin

A bay dun (E/E A/A D/d cr/cr) and a buckskin (E/E A/A d/d Cr/cr) have a foal. Every foal is bay-based. Work out the two dilution genes separately, then multiply:

  • Dun: D/d × d/d gives ½ dun, ½ non-dun.
  • Cream: cr/cr × Cr/cr gives ½ one copy of cream, ½ no cream.
FoalDunCreamChance
Baynono½ × ½ = ¼
Bay dunyesno½ × ½ = ¼
Buckskinnoyes½ × ½ = ¼
Dunskin (buckskin + dun)yesyes½ × ½ = ¼

Check it in the calculator.

Dun gene crosses

Dun × non-dun: D/d × d/d

A bay dun carrying one D, crossed with a bay:

Dd
dD/d bay dund/d bay
dD/d bay dund/d bay

½ bay dun, ½ bay. Check it.

Two duns: D/d × D/d

Dd
DD/D bay dunD/d bay dun
dD/d bay dund/d bay

¾ bay dun, ¼ bay: the classic 3:1, because D/D and D/d look alike. Check it.

Two copies of dun: D/D × d/d

A red dun with two copies (e/e D/D) crossed with a chestnut (e/e d/d) can only pass on D, so every foal is a red dun (D/d). Check it. Because D/D and D/d look the same, you can’t tell by looking which a dun horse is; its foals, or a DNA test, tell you.

Grullo × red dun: three genes at once

A grullo (E/e a/a D/d) and a red dun (e/e a/a D/d). Base color: E/e × e/e gives ½ black-based, ½ chestnut. Dun: D/d × D/d gives ¾ dun.

FoalWorkingChance
Grullo½ × ¾3/8
Red dun½ × ¾3/8
Black½ × ¼1/8
Chestnut½ × ¼1/8

Check it.

Two kinds of non-dun

Most domestic horses are non-dun, and a 2016 study found that there are two different non-dun alleles, both caused by changes near TBX3 that switch it off in part of the hair follicle:

AlleleBody colorPrimitive markingsOrigin
D (dun)DilutedYesFound in ancient horse DNA from before domestication
nd1 (non-dun1)Not dilutedOften present, but faint and variableAlso found in ancient horse DNA from before domestication
nd2 (non-dun2)Not dilutedAbsentA deletion that seems to have arisen more recently, probably after domestication

D is dominant to both non-dun alleles, and nd1 is dominant to nd2 for the markings. That explains a puzzle owners noticed for years: some horses have a dorsal stripe or faint leg bars but no dun dilution. Many of them carry nd1.

The CrossCalc calculator merges nd1 and nd2 into one non-dun allele, d. That gives the right answer for dun versus non-dun, but it can’t tell you whether a non-dun foal will have faint markings.

Is dun the wild type?

The researchers who identified the dun gene describe dun as the wild-type coat color of horses: a camouflage color that most domestic horses have lost. A horse that lived about 43,000 years ago carried both the dun allele and the nd1 allele, so both existed long before people domesticated horses. The UC Davis Veterinary Genetics Laboratory also describes dun with primitive markings as the wild-type state, seen in Przewalski’s horses, zebras and wild asses. Exactly how and when non-dun spread in domestic horses is still an open question.

Common questions

Is dun dominant or recessive?

Dominant. One copy of D gives a dun color, and two copies look the same as one. So in this model a dun horse must have at least one dun parent.

Can two non-dun horses have a dun foal?

Not in this model. Two non-dun parents have no D to pass on, so every foal is non-dun. A foal that looks dun but has two non-dun parents usually has another explanation, such as a buckskin color, or a non-dun1 horse with faint markings.

What is the difference between buckskin and dun?

They’re different genes. Buckskin is a bay with one copy of cream, which lightens the red body and leaves the black points. Bay dun is a bay with the dun gene, which lightens the body and adds primitive markings such as a dorsal stripe. A horse can have both (a dunskin).

Are horses with tiger stripes on their legs dun?

Often, but not always. Leg barring is a primitive marking that dun horses usually show, but non-dun1 horses can show faint barring too. A diluted body color plus markings points to dun; a DNA test settles it.

Is a grullo the same as a gray horse?

No. A grullo is a black horse with the dun gene: its slate-gray body color stays the same through its life, with dark points and markings. A gray horse is born colored and turns white with age because of a different gene.

Practice

  1. A red dun (e/e D/d) and a chestnut (e/e d/d) have a foal. What’s the chance it is a red dun?
  2. A grullo has a non-dun foal. What does that tell you about the grullo’s dun genotype?
  3. A bay horse has a faint dorsal stripe but its body isn’t diluted. Give one genetic explanation.
Answers
  1. ½. The cross is D/d × d/d: ½ D/d (red dun) and ½ d/d (chestnut). Check it.
  2. The grullo must be D/d. The non-dun foal got a non-dun allele from each parent, and a D/D grullo would have no non-dun allele to give.
  3. It could carry the non-dun1 allele, which often gives faint primitive markings without the dun dilution. (Countershading can also look like a stripe; a DNA test would tell.)

Where the model stops

  • Three alleles, not two. The calculator’s d stands for both non-dun alleles, so it can’t predict faint markings on non-dun foals.
  • Markings vary. The number and strength of primitive markings varies between dun horses, and isn’t predicted by the model.
  • Look-alikes. Cream, champagne and dun all lighten coats, and they can be combined. Telling them apart by eye can be hard, which is why separate DNA tests exist.
  • Names. Color names such as grullo, grulla, mouse dun or blue dun differ between breeds and registries.

Across species: dun and wild coat colors. Many wild animals have a pale body and darker markings that help them blend in, and dun is the horse’s version. Dun changes where pigment goes around each hair. A different gene, agouti (ASIP), changes pigment along each hair, giving the banded hairs of wild-type mice and tabby cats. In horses, agouti decides bay or black.

Sources

  • Imsland F, et al. “Regulatory mutations in TBX3 disrupt asymmetric hair pigmentation that underlies Dun camouflage color in horses.” Nature Genetics 48, 152–158 (2016). doi:10.1038/ng.3475
  • Uppsala University. “A horse of a different colour: genetics of camouflage and the Dun pattern” (press release on Imsland et al., 21 Dec 2015). uu.se
  • UC Davis Veterinary Genetics Laboratory. “Dun Dilution.” vgl.ucdavis.edu/test/dun-horse
  • UC Davis Veterinary Genetics Laboratory. “Equine Coat Color Genetics.” vgl.ucdavis.edu
  • Melvin K, Ivey J, Johnston L. Equine Genetics: Basic Coat Color Inheritance (W 891). University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture. utia.tennessee.edu
Try it: work out any cross with the horse coat color calculator, or a general one with the Punnett square calculator.