Palomino genetics: The cream gene, buckskin and cremello

Table of contents
  1. One copy, two copies: the six cream colors
  2. Why cream is incomplete dominance
  3. Worked crosses
  4. Palomino × palomino: Cr/cr × Cr/cr
  5. Cremello × chestnut: Cr/Cr × cr/cr
  6. Cremello × black: e/e A/A Cr/Cr × E/E a/a cr/cr
  7. A hidden cream: smoky black × chestnut
  8. Buckskin vs dun
  9. Common questions
  10. Is the palomino gene dominant?
  11. Can two palominos have a chestnut foal?
  12. Is a cremello an albino?
  13. Are palomino and champagne the same?
  14. Practice
  15. Where the model stops
  16. Related
  17. Sources

Level: High school · You’ll need: a monohybrid cross and the three base colors · Part of horse genetics

Palomino genetics comes down to one gene and one copy. A palomino is a chestnut horse with one copy of the cream allele Cr. Cream lightens red pigment, so the chestnut’s red coat becomes gold, and the mane and tail become pale. With two copies, the same chestnut becomes a cremello: a very pale cream horse with pink skin and blue eyes. Because one copy and two copies look different, cream is a textbook example of incomplete dominance.

Assumptions for the crosses on this page: the cream gene with two alleles, Cr (cream) and cr (no cream), the base-color genes shown, other genes held the same, and enough foals for the ratios to show. Genetic test reports often write cr as N (so N/Cr instead of Cr/cr).

One copy, two copies: the six cream colors

The cream gene is SLC45A2 (it used to be called MATP). A single change in it makes the Cr allele. One copy mostly dilutes red pigment and has a very small effect on black pigment. Two copies strongly dilute both.

Base colorNo cream (cr/cr)One copy (Cr/cr)Two copies (Cr/Cr)
Chestnut (e/e)ChestnutPalomino: gold body, pale mane and tailCremello
Bay (E/- A/-)BayBuckskin: gold body, black mane, tail and legsPerlino
Black (E/- a/a)BlackSmoky black: looks black or slightly fadedSmoky cream

Horses with two copies are very pale, with pink skin and blue eyes, whatever their base color, so cremellos, perlinos and smoky creams can be hard to tell apart by eye.

Why cream is incomplete dominance

With complete dominance, one copy of an allele looks the same as two copies (A/A and A/a are both bay). With cream, the three genotypes give three different colors:

  • cr/cr: full color
  • Cr/cr: one dose of dilution (palomino on chestnut)
  • Cr/Cr: two doses of dilution (cremello on chestnut)

That’s why the phenotype ratio for a cream cross matches the genotype ratio: every genotype has its own look.

One twist: on a black horse, one copy barely shows. So for black-based horses, cream behaves almost like a recessive allele, and a smoky black can pass on cream without anyone noticing.

Worked crosses

Palomino × palomino: Cr/cr × Cr/cr

Both parents are chestnut (e/e) with one copy of cream:

Crcr
CrCr/Cr cremelloCr/cr palomino
crCr/cr palominocr/cr chestnut

¼ chestnut, ½ palomino, ¼ cremello: a 1 : 2 : 1 ratio. Two palominos never “breed true”: each foal has only a ½ chance of being palomino. Check it in the calculator.

The same cross on bay horses gives ¼ bay, ½ buckskin, ¼ perlino. Check it.

Cremello × chestnut: Cr/Cr × cr/cr

A cremello has only Cr to pass on, and a chestnut has only cr. Every foal is Cr/cr: palomino. Check it.

Cremello × black: e/e A/A Cr/Cr × E/E a/a cr/cr

This one needs three genes. Every foal gets E from the black parent and A from the cremello, so every foal is bay-based (E/e A/a). Every foal also gets one Cr. All foals are buckskin. The cremello’s hidden A shows up only in its foals. Check it.

A hidden cream: smoky black × chestnut

A smoky black (E/E a/a Cr/cr) looks black. Crossed with a chestnut that carries A (e/e A/A cr/cr), every foal is bay-based, and half get the Cr: ½ bay, ½ buckskin. A buckskin foal from a “black” parent and a chestnut is a clue that the black parent was smoky black. Check it.

Buckskin vs dun

A buckskin and a bay dun can look alike: both have a light body with black points. They come from different genes. Buckskin is a bay with one copy of cream, which lightens the red body. Dun (TBX3) is a separate dominant gene that lightens the body and adds primitive markings, most often a dark stripe down the back. A horse can have both: a buckskin with dun is sometimes called a dunskin. The dun gene page compares the two side by side.

Common questions

Is the palomino gene dominant?

Partly. Cream is incompletely dominant: one copy gives a palomino (on a chestnut), and two copies give a cremello, which looks different again.

Can two palominos have a chestnut foal?

Yes. Each foal of two palominos has a ¼ chance of being cr/cr, which is chestnut.

Is a cremello an albino?

Not in the usual sense. A cremello’s hair is pale cream rather than pigment-free, and it still has its other color genes, which it passes on to its foals. The cream gene, SLC45A2, is the same gene behind one type of albinism in people (see the box below).

Are palomino and champagne the same?

No. Champagne (SLC36A1) is a different, dominant gene that lightens both red and black pigment. A gold champagne can look like a palomino, but champagne horses have mottled skin and light amber or green eyes as adults.

Practice

  1. A palomino and a chestnut have a foal. What’s the chance it is palomino?
  2. Two buckskins (E/E A/A Cr/cr) have a foal. List the possible colors and their chances.
  3. A cremello and a palomino (both e/e) have a foal. What colors are possible?
Answers
  1. ½. The cross is Cr/cr × cr/cr, which gives ½ Cr/cr (palomino) and ½ cr/cr (chestnut).
  2. ¼ bay (cr/cr), ½ buckskin (Cr/cr), ¼ perlino (Cr/Cr): the same 1 : 2 : 1 as palominos, on a bay base.
  3. Cr/Cr × Cr/cr gives ½ Cr/Cr (cremello) and ½ Cr/cr (palomino). No chestnut foals are possible, because the cremello always passes on Cr.

Where the model stops

  • One gene at a time. The worked crosses hold every other gene the same. In real horses, other dilution and pattern genes can be present too.
  • Shade varies. Palominos and buckskins range from pale to dark gold; a coat name is a color group, not an exact shade.
  • Look-alikes. Champagne and dun also lighten coats. Telling them apart by eye can be hard, which is why genetic tests for each gene exist.

Across species: the same gene in mice and people. SLC45A2, the horse cream gene, is the gene behind “underwhite” mice and oculocutaneous albinism type 4 in people. Other pigment genes give similar dilutions in other animals: dilute cats carry a change in MLPH, and albino mice have a broken Tyr gene.

Sources

  • UC Davis Veterinary Genetics Laboratory. “Cream.” vgl.ucdavis.edu/test/cream
  • Mariat D, Taourit S, Guérin G. “A mutation in the MATP gene causes the cream coat colour in the horse.” Genetics Selection Evolution 35, 119–133 (2003). doi:10.1186/1297-9686-35-1-119
  • Cook D, et al. “Missense mutation in exon 2 of SLC36A1 responsible for champagne dilution in horses.” PLoS Genetics 4, e1000195 (2008). doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1000195
  • Imsland F, et al. “Regulatory mutations in TBX3 disrupt asymmetric hair pigmentation that underlies Dun camouflage color in horses.” Nature Genetics 48, 152–158 (2016). doi:10.1038/ng.3475
  • OpenStax. Biology 2e, 12.2 “Characteristics and Traits” (incomplete dominance). openstax.org
Try it: work out any cross with the horse coat color calculator, or a general one with the Punnett square calculator.